Business ideas – the good, the bad and the crazy

One expert and three business owners discuss business ideas and how success can sometimes come from seemingly foolish thoughts.

Although a few businesses ideas are unique, many involve what Kevin Duncan describes as “conceptual blending”, which is taking an idea and applying it in a new context. “Add the delivery mechanism of a biro to stick deodorant and you invent roll-on deodorant,” he explains.

Duncan is a business adviser, marketing expert and author of more than 20 books for small businesses, including The Ideas Book: 50 Ways to Generate Ideas Visually. “Anyone can have a business idea,” he continues. “But if enough people aren’t willing to buy it to cover your costs and generate enough profit – you have no business.”

Asking potential customers as early as possible what they think of your business idea – and how much they would pay for it – is essential. “Before starting up, the founders of Innocent set up a stall at a jazz festival with ‘good’ and ‘bad’ bins. All people had to do was lob their empty smoothie container into one bin or the other. Easy, fast, reliable market research.”

“Many advisers say you should ‘always be in beta’, but I disagree. Get it right at the beginning and get on with it.”

Promising ideas can be refined, says Duncan, who believes you should test fast, then decide. “Many advisers say you should ‘always be in beta’, but I disagree. Get it right at the beginning and then get on with it.”

Duncan also believes in speaking to experts if you lack technical knowledge, because their input can make a big difference. “When testing business ideas you must be brutally honest,” Duncan stresses. “If it’s rubbish, start again. And again. If your ideas are never good enough, admit it and give up. It could save you a lot of time, money and grief.”

Recipe for success

“I came up with the idea while sitting at home thinking there had to be a better way to cook great meals without all the hard work,” recalls Timo Boldt. “Having to find recipes, go shopping, and weigh ingredients was painful, while inevitably you end up wasting food. I thought if someone could fix this for less than the supermarkets charge, it would be insanely amazing.”

Boldt started London-based Gousto in 2012 with friend James Carter. Customers can visit the website, pick recipes and then order pre-measured ingredients to ensure no waste, which soon arrive at their door. “We made many small changes before launching, but our first real customer feedback triggered much bigger changes,’ Schmidt confesses.

“Customer feedback is vital. We still obsess about listening to our customers – they drive our product roadmap.”

Soon they were testing their recipes from market stalls, where reaction was overwhelmingly positive, but they were still able to learn. Boldt says it’s essential to test a business idea thoroughly before committing time and money. “Customer feedback is vital. We still obsess about listening to our customers – they drive our entire product roadmap,” he says.

In less than four years Gousto has scaled to now support more than 200 jobs, selling millions of meals per year. It has attracted £20m of investment, while ex-LOVEFILM CEO, Simon Calver, now sits on the company’s board. Always seeking new ideas, Gousto has launched apps to make ordering even more convenient, while introducing more choice to the menu (which now features dishes created by Theo Randall and Mary Berry, as well as wine and desserts). “You must take time to develop ideas – but sometimes it does take a leap of faith,” Boldt smiles.

“While enjoying food and drink with friends, Kahana lifted up his feet. He wondered why most socks looked so boring.”

Socks appeal

Gil Kahana and Humberto De Sousa became friends while studying communication design at Central Saint Martins. One day they were enjoying food and drink with friends and as Kahana relaxed he lifted up his feet. He wondered why most socks looked so boring. Then he got around to thinking how much better socks could be if animated with characters (“almost like wearing sock puppets on your feet”).

“I suggested the idea to Humberto and asked if he would like to collaborate. Then we started to meet up once a week to progress the idea, because we both had full-time jobs,” he says. “We drew quirky faces onto white socks, to see what worked best. At first we didn’t really have any business ambitions, but it grew. We then asked people on the street in London for their views on personal expression through clothing. It confirmed our thinking: the characters on our socks should only become visible when shoes were taken off.”

Chatty Feet launched in 2012 and feedback was mostly positive, says Kahana. “One blog made a negative comment, but it didn’t stop us,” he adds. Now with such characters as Kate Middle-Toe, Prof Brian Sox, Andy Sock-Hole, they sell socks in 27 designs in nine countries. “Last year we doubled our unit sales and we’re currently looking to open up new overseas markets,” Kahana reveals.

When seeking feedback, Kahana recommends having a prototype. “Then people can see exactly what you’re talking about. Also carry out research to make sure someone hasn’t already got there. Discussing your ideas with others can be beneficial, but make sure you’re in a stimulating environment. You should feel able to express your thoughts. Some people see the world in strict paradigms; they struggle with new ideas. Don’t listen to them,” he advises.

“The Dragons abused me in their typical style – even saying that my product was dangerous. Afterwards I was angry, but determined to show them.”

Buoyant sales

Kevin Moseley was a swimming instructor in Lancashire in the late-1980s. For a fun way to end lessons he would pretend to be a shark and swim around the pool wearing a fin made from two polystyrene kickboards. One day a child asked if he could try the fin, because it looked fun. Moseley experienced his own eureka moment, realising the commercial potential.

“Over some years I created, tested and improved prototypes,” he remembers. “I’d taken out a trade mark and had patents pending when I was invited to appear on Dragons’ Den in 2006. The Dragons abused me in their typical style – even saying that my product was dangerous. Afterwards I was angry, but determined to show them.”

Kevin remortgaged his home, borrowed from the bank, cashed in his life savings and sold his swimming school business to raise start-up capital. “It was a huge gamble, risking everything on an idea seeking to change the way swimming is taught around the world. I could never have been 100 per cent sure it would succeed,’ he confesses.

Moseley modified his product, had it tested rigorously against international safety standards. “I spent 18 months on R&D. You can’t launch a swimming aid without thorough testing – parents must be able to trust your products.” Then he found a manufacturer and launched Northampton-based SwimFin in 2008, running the business from his garage.

“In our first year we sold about 70,000 units in 46 countries overseas – a promising start. Now we export to more than 100 countries, have 44 exclusive international distributors and in the next year we hope to sell our one millionth SwimFin. We have a range of products, but the pioneering SwimFin is still the bestseller. I’m very proud of my idea and the business.”

• Written for The Guardian Small Business Network by Dead Good Content founder, Mark Williams.

My biggest leap of faith

Taking risks is part and parcel of being in business, but some are particularly significant. Mark Williams asks five entrepreneurs to look back to a time when they took a leap of faith.

Wendy Tan White’s first major leap of faith wasn’t, as you might expect, when she started Moonfruit with Joe White and Eirik Pettersen during the first dotcom boom. It was carrying on when the dotcom bubble burst in 2001, she reveals.

“Funding ran out, so we had to cut the team from 60, to 10, then two, which was very tough,” she says. “But we totally believed in our mission to enable small firms to build their own websites.” By 2012, when the business was sold to the Yell Group for £23m, seven million websites had been built using the pioneering Moonfruit platform.

Tan White admits that leaps of faith still “bring the same vertigo and butterflies”, even after years in business. Her latest, 18 months ago, saw Tan White and husband Joe join Entrepreneur First (EF), the London tech accelerator started by Matt Clifford and Alice Bentinck in 2011. “We joined because we want to help the best talent to build world-class startups from scratch. We were also looking for something that was worth betting our time and money on,” she says. “Matt and Alice are exceptional people.”

In May, Entrepreneur First had its first major exit, when Twitter acquired AI start-up Magic Pony for $150m. “We’ve raised £40m to extend EF’s company-building programme from six months to two years, and invest further in companies. We’ve personally invested in 12 businesses in our portfolio of 20 – and mentor many more. Becoming investors has been a totally different leap of faith.”

I was continually being told people wouldn’t buy online, but the business grew to be worth £250m – Chris Barling

Software solutions

Tech entrepreneur Chris Barling was 40 when he took a life-changing chance to set up his own business. “I left a well-paid job with Cable & Wireless to set up [ecommerce software provider] Actinic in 1996,” he says. “My co-founder and I funded the launch and my family of five had to live on £8,000 in that first year.”

Software development involves considerable investment before any revenue comes in, he adds, often leaving owners short of cash. “It was a major leap of faith. I was continually being told people wouldn’t buy online, but the business grew to be worth £250m.”

Barling estimates £10bn of sales went through Actinic-powered websites before he moved on in 2014. He now sits on the board of a FTSE 100 company and two high-growth tech startups. And he has started Powered Now, a provider of invoice, estimating and scheduling mobile software for small trade businesses, such as plumbers, electricians and builders.

“Again, I’m told trades people will never be keen on technology to run their business. [But] they will, because now it’s mobile, like them, and simpler. It’s taken personal investment, but now we have more than 1,100 paying customers and 60,000 trade businesses have downloaded our app. Entrepreneurs must sometimes take leaps of faith. It’s hard, but can bring the biggest rewards. It should never be an [unconsidered one] though.”

Space man

“In 2012, after Airbnb started to take off, it just came to me and stayed in my head,” says 24-year-old Ross Bailey of starting his business Appear Here. “Maybe something similar could help fill the huge number of empty UK retail premises.”

To test this theory, Bailey and a friend took a short-term let on premises near Carnaby Street and sold T-shirts to coincide with the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee.

Others showed interest and the viability of the pop-up shop concept became clear. The company launched in February 2013 and is now a leading online marketplace that connects landlords with brands and businesses seeking short-term retail space in the UK.

My leap of faith was simply telling others about my idea. Some said it was rubbish, but one person said I shouldn’t over-think it – Ross Bailey

“My leap of faith was simply telling others about my idea,” Bailey reveals. “Some said it was rubbish, but one person said I shouldn’t over-think it. Try it out and if it fails, it fails.

“There’s something powerful about telling people about your idea. Many people want you to succeed. Ultimately, you win or you lose, but the initial momentum begins.” Appear Here now has offices in London and Paris and more than 40 employees, having raised some £5m in funding.

Growth platform

Saurav Chopra took a chance in 2014 when he cofounded Perkbox, a platform employers pay to use to provide employees with “access to more than 200 perks, an online reward and recognition system and a wellness hub”.

Chopra explains: “Parent company Huddlebuy was a highly profitable lead-generation business, turning over £1m-plus, but we wanted to build something we could scale worldwide. [Starting a new business] that wasn’t generating any revenue required a huge leap of faith.”

Justifying the idea to his board, investors and employees was incredibly hard, admits Chopra, and Perkbox was one year in the making before launching in 2015. “Just two years after deciding to pivot, revenue has grown by 13 times, and we’ve gone from 15 employees to 100, without any external funding.”

Chopra believes that entrepreneurs must regularly take leaps of faith – these are mostly small, but occasionally very significant. “They key is to minimise risk,” he says. “Evaluate as much data as possible; get input from key team members; and feedback from potential customers. Once the decision’s been made, you must communicate your rationale and plan to the rest of the team.”

I’m a passionate Liverpool FC fan and the thought of a short drive to Anfield was too much to resist – Steve McGauley

Mersey paradise

Steve McGauley’s leap of faith involved relocating his marketing agency from London to Liverpool. “I started Liquid in 2000. Three years later, after growing steadily, moving to the north west seemed the next natural step.

“I’m Yorkshire born, but my dad’s a Scouser and my family live in the north – it’s where I feel most comfortable. I considered Manchester and Leeds, but I’m a passionate Liverpool FC fan and the thought of a short drive to Anfield was too much to resist,” he laughs.

While it was a big move, McGauley says agencies don’t need a London postcode to compete. “We have a high success rate of winning work against agencies regionally and in London,” he adds. “We have the same work ethic and creativity, but charge less usually.” Liquid now has 17 employees and an impressive client list that includes Levis, Warburtons and Liverpool John Lennon Airport.

The main reason for relocating was better quality of life, he says, particularly at a time when he and his wife wanted to start a family. “London consumes you; working very long hours is expected. Personally, I never had any doubts. I believed in my business and in Liverpool.

Moving to Liverpool has been one of my best decisions. The talent and drive here reminds me of London, but the people in Liverpool tend to do things with a smile on their face – Steve McGauley

“I’m thankful for my time in London,” he adds, “but moving to Liverpool has been one of my best decisions ever. The talent and drive here reminds me of London, but the people in Liverpool tend to do things with a smile on their face.”

While leaps of faith can be terrifying, when they’re taken with careful consideration of the risks and benefits on the line, they can be the push that a business needs to grow and thrive. What will your next leap of faith be?

• Written by Dead Good Content founder, Mark Williams, this feature appeared originally on the Small Business Network pages of The Guardian website in 2016.

Create your own low-cost customer enewsletter in five simple steps

In my previous post, I made the business case for enewsletters, which can be a highly effective marketing tool for accountants and other service-based businesses. For little cost, you can market your services to prospects, current and former customers.

But what are the key legal considerations and what steps should you take if you want to your enewsletter to succeed?   

1 Build and segment your enewsletter contact list…

Obviously, you’ll have email addresses for existing clients. And although you may have them for former clients and prospects, if you haven’t gained their informed consent, email them all to tell them about your new enewsletter, including a link to your website’s enewsletter subscription page.

Gather your signed-up email addresses into one enewsletter contact database. Segmenting this into different types of customers and targeting each with variations of your enewsletter can greatly increase your success. Separating private individuals from businesses is an obvious place to start, but you could segment your database into leads, customers and previous customers.

Top tip >> Segment your business customers by age, size or sector, so that you can better serve their specific information needs.

2 Get more subscribers to sign up

Enabling visitors to easily subscribe via your home page and others is a must. Give links good visibility, but avoid invasive pop-ups and anything else that could annoy.

Don’t ask for too much information at first. You just need a name, some basic details and an email address. On your sign-up web page, tell subscribers how you’ll use their email address. If you plan to send other marketing emails, allow them to opt out. Include enewsletter sign-up links in your email footers and social media posts and profile pages. Publicise your enewsletter offline, too.

Top tip >> Don’t waste money buying email lists, because the quality can be poor. Instead, always seek to grow your subscription list.

3 Draw up an enewsletter content plan

Create this for the next 12 months. Plan in content when it will be most relevant and useful to recipients. As an obvious example, if you are an accountant, you include a piece on Self-Assessment in your November or December enewsletter ahead of the 31 January tax return online filing deadline.

Also align content with your marketing aims. For example, you may want to try to sell a particular service at a certain time, so you include related content in the preceding month’s enewsletter.

You should also plan content around topical, seasonal, national or international events. Provide an engaging mix of topics and content format in each newsletter. Be original. About three items of content per newsletter is a good target – think quality not quantity. This content should live on your website. Create an archive page, so visitors can read your previous enewsletters.

Top tip >> Your content should be rich in value. Tell recipients something new. Solve their problems. Help them to succeed. Save them time and money. Also showcase your expertise.       

4 Choose the right enewsletter solution

There are many enewsletter management platforms/apps. They include MailChimp, Mailjet, GetResponse, MailUp, MailerLite, Emma, Campaign Monitor, Constant Contact, MailUp, AWeber, Benchmark, Sendloop, SendinBlue and ConvertKit.

Some offer a free service, with limited features/benefits, but these can still work well if you have a relatively short mailing list. The more you pay, basically, the more you get, and monthly deals are available from about £10-£15 – a relatively low investment.

So, how does they work? You import your database, create an enewsletter design or use/customise a responsive template (so your email looks good on all devices) and schedule your distribution. Most paid solutions enable you to segment, A/B test, custom brand your enewsletters and gain advanced audience insights, so you can improve your success rate.

Top tip >> Make it easy to share your newsletters via email links or social media sharing buttons. It can help to grow your subscription list.

5 Preview, send and analyse

After all of your content has been written – and proofed – most enewsletter platforms/apps allow you send test versions to yourself, to check it looks good on desktop and mobile device, and won’t be deemed junk mail. If all is OK, you can send or schedule your enewsletter for distribution.

You can never be totally sure how your enewsletter will perform, but most enewsletter platforms/apps provide analytics, so you can see what worked and what didn’t. Key metrics include open rate, click-through rate and unsubscribe rates.

Top tip >> Always analyse performance data. Learn lessons and make improvements. Don’t give up if results aren’t great straight away. Success takes time and effort.

Some important legal requirements

• Your must comply with General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requirements when it comes to personal data.

• Recipients should also have given their explicit consent to receiving your enewsletter. Individuals and organisations must opt-in to receive your email. Get verifiable consent via an affirmative action.

• Recipients must be able to unsubscribe easily.

• Each enewsletter must clearly state your business name, registration number if a limited company, your postal and email addresses. You can’t conceal your identity.

• Anti-spam laws restrict the sending of “spam” (unsolicited marketing emails) to subscribers.

• Never send unsolicited enewsletters. Most of us hate them – don’t we?

• Written by Mark Williams, founder and content director of Dead Good Content. Copyright 2020 © Dead Good Content.